Red Herring Scarf Knitting Pattern

Red Herring Scarf

This handsome, unisex scarf features a herringbone stitch with a moss stitch border. This pattern is suitable for beginning knitters.

Placeholder Ad

FREE! Download (pdf, 244K)

  • 01/11/2009: New pattern template, but no major changes to the instructions.
  • 09/23/2008: I seem to have overridden the corrected version of the pattern by accident during an update. If you downloaded this pattern between 07/11/2008 and now, please download and use this version instead. I’ve also updated the link to
  • 01/06/2007: Error in herringbone stitch w/moss stitch border pattern fixed.
  • 01/05/2007: Notes added for clarity.

Although this pattern is available free for non-commercial use, please consider making a small donation in support of the time and effort that went into this design. Thank you!

Placeholder Ad

Red Herring Scarf, closeup

Skill Level: Beginner

Size: 8" (20 cm) wide x 60" (150 cm) long w/o fringe

Yarn: Rowan Cashsoft DK (50% extra-fine merino wool, 40% microfiber, 10% cashmere; 142 yds/130 m per 1¾ oz/50 g), shown in #521; 4 skeins

A note on yarn selection: This pattern uses a stockinette-based stitch and thus has a strong tendency to curl. If using Rowan Cashsoft DK, you may wish to block and iron the finished scarf to reduce this tendency.

If substituting yarn, it’s recommended to choose a yarn that is mostly natural fiber. In addition, the zigzag/striping effect will show up best in a yarn with good stitch definition and a bit of sheen.

This pattern is simple enough to be a first or second project for a new knitter or a quick, easy knit for a more advanced knitter. The combination of the moss stitch and herringbone stitch would make a good exercise for learning how to read your knitting. This pattern includes:

  • Increasing
  • Decreasing
  • Blocking

If You Like This, You May Also Like:

Placeholder Ad


  1. seema says:

    I am doing this pattern for the first time and the numbers dont add up. Am I doing something wrong? I casted on 49 stitches. I did the herringbone stitch w/moss stitch row 1 and there was one stitch remaning. What am i doing wrong?


  2. Yvonne says:

    Hi seema,

    I don’t know exactly what you’re doing, but hopefully this will help you work the numbers out.

    When you start the herringbone w/moss stitch border pattern you should have 49 stitches.

    p1, k1, p1 (3 stitches worked)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — the k2tog and the inc 1 offset each other — 9 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 15 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 21 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 27 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 33 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 39 stitches total)

    [k2tog, k2, inc 1, k2] (6 more stitches worked — 45 stitches total, 4 stitches left)

    k1, p1, k1, p1 (4 stitches worked — 49 stitches total)

    You’ll be doing the six-stitch repeat 7 times total, for 42 stitches, and make sure not to forget the k1 after you finish the repeats before you go back to the moss stitch border.

  3. Deborah says:

    I’m just about to start the pattern but I have a question about the fringe. I might have missed it but I couldn’t find anything on how to add the fringe in the pattern. Should it be added before you start the scarf or after the scarf’s been finished, and how do you add it?

  4. Andrew says:

    Hi. I’m just about to start this project and had a question. What blocking method did you use? In your pictures the scarf looks almost completely flat. Most of what I have read has been wet and steam press blocking.

  5. Joe says:

    What am I missing. If the border is moss stitch and the last four stitches of row 1 are:

    k1, p1, k1, p1

    how can the first four stitches of row four be:

    k1, p1, k1, k1

    How does that continue the Moss Stitch pattern? Any thoughts? Is there a correction? Am I just not getting it?

  6. Yvonne says:

    Hi Joe,

    I think you’re mis-reading the pattern — it’s a 4-row repeat and row
    4 (all WS rows, actually) is purled all the way across. The second
    line of the pattern is for both rows 2 and 4.

    Row 1 (RS) starts with p1, k1, p1 and ends with p1, k1, p1

    Row 2 (WS) is purled all the way across.

    Row 3 starts with k1, p1, k1 and ends with k1, p1, k1, which continues
    the moss stitch border.

    Row 4 is also purled all the way across.

    Hope that helps,

  7. louwomack says:

    Is this the revised pattern? I’ve tried to follow the pattern, but no herring bone pattern appears.

  8. scott says:

    I believe there is an error in the pattern but it is in row 3 of the Herringbone w/ moss stitch. In order to truly reverse the pattern of row 1, row three should end with, P1,K1,P1, K1. (i.e. FOUR stitches not three)

    • Yvonne says:

      Hi scott,

      That is not an error. The moss stitch border only encompasses the first THREE and last THREE stitches of each row.

      Row 1 ends with k1, p1, k1, p1. The first k1 in that belongs to the herringbone panel. The p1, k1, p1 belong to the moss stitch border.

      Row 3 ends with k1, p1, k1 to finish the moss stitch border.

  9. Jamie says:

    Do you think that this scarf would be best using a wool acrlic blend or you think that a 100% alpaca (baby) in dk would work as well. I’m only starting in knitting, teaching myself, and it is hard for me to judge yarn to patterns to how something will wear when done (drape/sage/hold shape). Any help would be nice. Thanks. I’m really excited to make this for a good friend for Christmas.

    • Yvonne says:

      Hi Jamie,

      I wouldn’t consider either of those yarns to be ideal for this pattern. You’ll have a hard time blocking the wool/acrylic blend if it’s more than 20% acrylic. Since this scarf is a stockinette-based pattern, that means it will want to keep curling up on itself.

      The 100% alpaca would be easier to block flat, but alpaca is fuzzy and I’m afraid that might obscure the pattern. This pattern really works best with a smooth and a bit shiny yarn.

      I hope that helps.

      • Jamie says:

        Is the Rowan Cashsoft DK very soft? I live in the boonies so I would have to order it on-line and have no retail outlet near here where I could “feel” for myself. I really would like the scarf to be super soft and not scratchy.

      • Jamie says:

        I just opened my Knitpicks e-mail for their new “gloss” DK it is 70% Merino and 30% Silk, looks nice *smiles*.

        Knitpicks Gloss DK

        Mod edit to fix link

      • Yvonne says:

        Jamie –

        Out of those two yarns, I’d go with the Knitpicks gloss DK. The Rowan Cashsoft is very soft, but it’s also 40% microfiber and doesn’t block well.

      • Tallguy says:

        I don’t understand why you say alpaca is fuzzy! That is clearly not true. I don’t know where you get your yarns, but mine are all worsted spun, very smooth and shiny and give excellent stitch definition. It does lay very flat and has wonderful drape. I feel it is very wrong of you to make such misleading statements about a great fibre for this scarf. You do a disservice to other knitters that simply have never experienced this wonderful yarn.

      • Yvonne says:

        With all due, respect, Tallguy, alpaca can be quite fuzzy.

        Just look at the middle pictures on this post. You can clearly see the halo and bloom around the 100% alpaca yarn. This is a characteristic of many alpaca yarns on the market, even alpaca blends.

        I say alpaca isn’t suitable for this pattern because to get the shiny/striping effect from the herringbone, it works best if the yarn doesn’t bloom much. I didn’t say alpaca is a bad fiber, but it is not what I would recommend for this pattern. There are many patterns out there that take advantage of the wonderful properties of alpaca. This isn’t one of them.

  10. xina says:

    I’m knitting this scarf right now. I’m using Caron Simply Soft and #8 needles and its turning out great. Thanks for the beautiful pattern!

  11. jh says:

    If the last row of the moss stitch is WS purl, shouldn’t step 6 be RS knit, bind off? Am I missing something? Thanks, love the pattern.

    • Yvonne says:

      Ooh, you’re right! I think I actually meant that to be (RS) Purl, so that the bind-off row would create a row of purl bumps to match the purl bumps created by the long-tail cast-on. Though (RS) Knit would be just fine.

      Thanks for letting me know!

  12. Keely says:


    I love your pattern but am confused about one thing.

    In row 3 of the moss border and herringbone stitch I only count 48 stitches. Row 1 worked fine for me because after the herringbone repetition there were 4 stitches to wrap it up, but on row 3 as there are only 3 stitches I wind up short. Should it maybe be P1 to finish the herringbone pattern, and then k1,p1,k1 to finish the moss border?

    Thanks so much!

    • Yvonne says:

      Hi Keely,

      There are 49 stitches in row 3. There are 4 sts before the bracketed part (k1, p1, k2), then 42 sts in the bracketed repeats (6 sts repeated 7 times) and then 3 sts to finish it off.

      • keely says:

        Wow. All of that figuring and retrying things and it was a simple oversight. I had been starting row 3 with k1,p1,k1, instead of k1,p1,k2. Thanks so much for your help!

  13. Lazy Knits says:

    This scarf has a great texture, I love herringbone stitch, I think I might give this one a try!

  14. lpales says:

    I’m about to start this pattern with a much lighter weight yard. Should I just repeat the (6 st repeated 7 times) until it’s wide enough? Will I run into any potential problems? Thanks.

    • Yvonne says:

      That should work out just fine! Just make sure you cast on a multiple of 6 stitches +1 so the numbers work out right (e.g., 61 stitches or 73 stitches).

      The border takes 6 stitches (3 on either side).
      The center herringbone panel is a 6-stitch repeat + 1 extra stitch to finish the pattern.

  15. LiLo says:

    wow, so many probs with this pattern! Add me to the list…It’s just not working out for me — have no idea why.

    Is it possible to make this a different size? What is the ratio? Is it a multiple of 7 and X??

    Also, any way to work this beautiful herringbone stitch — I’m not giving up on it yet! — in the round? Would love to use it in the round.

    Please, someone respond! Thanks!

    • Yvonne says:

      Hi LiLo,

      Can you tell me what’s happening when you try to work it? As you can see from the comments above, a lot of people mis-read the pattern where the border transitions into the center panel.

      Yes, you can make it a different size. Just cast on a multiple of 6 stitches + 1 and follow the directions as written.

      Yes, you can work the herringbone pattern in the round. Drop off the 3 border stitches on either side and knit the even-numbered rows.

      Note: response was edited on 1/3/2012 because Emily S found an error!

      • LiLo says:

        Hey, thank you, Yvonne. It’s not often one gets replies back :^).
        I figured out what the problem is — for me, anyway, and perhaps for some others: For a krl increase (the one called for here), there is, of course 2 stitches worked — the one created and then the knitting of the stitch from which it came. When instructions then call for “k2,” it does not indicate whether that first k of the k2 is an entirely new stitch, or the knitting of the stitch from which one created the new stitch…Wow, hard to put into words! Ha. Anyway, maybe this will explain better: After the instruction to “inc1″ it should then read, “K the original/first stitch” or to somehow account for the original stitch, if you know what I mean ??
        I was counting the original stitch after the increaset as part of the “k2″ because there was no accounting for this stitch in the instructions.
        I incidentally came across a herringbone pattern last night, which read to, “m1 inc, then K the original s titch…” then it read to “K2.” This made it clear, and accounted for each stitch: So then I knew that I needed to actually create one more stitch after the increase THEN do the k2.

        sorry for the wordiness! It’s hard to describe.

      • Yvonne says:

        Hi LiLo,

        I see what you mean!

        The instructions for the increase on the last page of the pattern do say to knit the next (original) stitch on the needle as part of the increase. How can I make it clearer?

  16. Alison says:

    Done with the scarf…thank you!

    How do you add fringe?

  17. Emily S says:

    I would like to decrease the size of this scarf, but I am confused by what multiple of stitches to do decrease it by. In your (Yvonne’s) response to lpales you say to increase/decrease it by multiples of 6 stitches +1. Then in your reply to LiLo you said to increase/decrease by multiples of 7. I always thought that those meant two different things, am I wrong? Which way is one supposed to increase/decrease the pattern? Thanks.

    • Yvonne says:

      ACK, you’re right! It’s supposed to be a multiple of 6 stitches + 1, as in the response to lpales. That response also explains why that works. A multiple of 7 will NOT work unless it happens to also be a multiple of 6 + 1 (like the original cast-on number, 49).

      I’ve edited my response to LiLo to show the correct multiplier and avoid further confusion.

      Thanks for catching that!

  18. lsm says:

    I have finished knitting the scarf which is really very nice. After wearing for 2 times, I find out thar the scarf roll up and become narrow. What can I do? I am using the woollen yarn as you suggested. How can I manage it back to be flat instead of rolling up?

  19. susie says:

    I’m looking at this pattern and don’t understand the herringbone pattern aspect. I’m an avid knitter but this part confuses me: Herringbone Stitch w/Moss Stitch Border
    Work all increases in the pattern as follows:
    From the front, knit into the right loop of the stitch below the next stitch on the left needle. Knit the next stitch on the left needle.
    This increase is the Knit Right Loop (KRL) increase demonstrated on

    any help you could provide would be amazing. I’ll definitely donate for the assistance!

    • CogKnition says:

      Hi Susie,

      Can you tell me more about what’s confusing you? Did you watch the video on the KRL increase online?

      In the pattern, every time it indicates that there’s an increase, you should do what’s shown in that video.


  20. Mauli says:

    Hi Yvonne,

    I was hoping to see if you had any tips on knowing whether the next row is Row 1 or Row 3 of the herring bone stitch by looking at the work? (Sometimes I forget which row I’m on -__-)


  21. Jo says:

    Hi – I would like to knit this pattern in 8 ply cashmere (jade sapphire). Would you recommend this yarn for this pattern, and would it curl?

    • CogKnition says:

      Jo » I’m not familiar with that yarn. Pretty much any yarn will curl, because it’s a stockinette-based pattern. Yarns that are natural fiber will be able to be blocked flat to some extent.

  22. Jo says:

    Hi I am using cashmere and it is rolling a lot. A lot!!! I will block when I finish but must I block after each wash?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will never be published or shared. Required fields are marked with *.

Allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

7 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] Project Title: Red Herring Scarf Modification: 37 Stitches on Size 9 Needles Final Length: 62” Minus Fringe [...]

  2. [...] J’ai aussi trouvé de la Rowan Cashsoft pour le foulard Red herring. Je l’ai acheté sur ebay pour moitié moins cher, reste à voir si ça valait la peine! [...]

  3. [...] la dernière fois j’ai terminé le Red Herring Scarf. Je dois avouer que je suis assez contente du résultat. C’est presque comme sur la photo du [...]

  4. [...] I have the amount of concentration it requires. I decided to switch to another pattern. I found Red Herring from CogKnition and it was perfect! I printed out the copy and finally, last night, decided to cast [...]

  5. [...] this category since there are two skeins of yarn that’s easy to tangle. I decided to go for Red Herring. A, because it’s really pretty. And B, because lately I’ve become addicted to the PBS [...]

  6. [...] and red flecks really making it have far more life and vibrancy than expected.  The pattern is Cogknition’s Red Herring Scarf but rather than a plan, smooth yarn the Rowan Yorkshire Tweed offers the opportunity to play with [...]

  7. -->
  8. Krispy Knits » Just One of Those Days…
  9. Krispy Knits » Accomplishments, New Things, and Way too Much To Do???
  10. C’est parti… « Rongeur tricoteur
  11. 1 an plus tard… « Le bonheur est dans le tricot
  12. The Scarf That Didn’t Want To Be « Just Knit!
  13. Staving off boredom « March301′s Weblog
  14. Knitting & Crochet Blog Week: Day 1 Colour (3KCBWDAY1) | Knitting but Never Conforming